So, there has been much contemplation of how good or bad the movie would be. Should one see the movie or skip it because it is so far from the book?
Well, Marc and I went to see it. I have to say, I was entertained. It held together just fine for me. There were some things that were changed from the book (and thanks to Gary, I have actually read the book). It was an entertaining view of the book. And understanding that movies are never the same as the book, I was not disappointed or overly critical. This also has to be read through the “Heather likes movies” lens. If it’s a movie, I like it. Most other people are infinitely more critical.
Reviewers have, overall, been less than kind. Shane sent on two reviews. Another reviewer that I read often, Teddy, hasn’t read the book, so he found the movie to be a fine cinematic adventure, but does point out that it’s British humor.
So, if it’s a problem that you want the book to match the movie, don’t see it. Otherwise, go see it and be entertained…
Posted by Heather Voss at May 6, 2005 08:41 AM